| Item | Item Type | Level | Item Effect | Crit Item Effect (Superior) | |
| Bronze Scholar's Glass | Tool | +1% Critical Chance | +2% Critical Chance, Tough | ||
| Iron Scholar's Glass | Tool | 13 | +4% Critical Chance | +5% Critical Chance, Tough | |
| Steel Scholar's Glass | Tool | 25 | +6% Critical Chance | +8% Critical Chance, Tough | |
| Dwarf-Steel Scholar's Glass | Tool | 35 | +10% Critical Chance | +12% Critical Chance, Tough | |
| Ancient Iron Scholar's Glass | Tool | 45 | +14% Critical Chance | +16% Critical Chance, Tough | |
| Ancient Steel Scholar's Glass | Tool | 45 | +18% Critical Chance | +20% Critical Chance, Tough | |
| Tools of the Historian | Tool | 55 | +18% Critical Chance (+18% Critical Weaponsmith, -2.8s Farming) |
+20% Critical Chance, Tough (+20% Critical Weaponsmith, -3s Farming) |
|
| Item | Item Type | Level | Item Effect | |
| Scroll of Minor Scholar Lore | Consumable | 7 | +1% Critical chance, Duration 1 minute | |
| Scroll of Lesser Scholar Lore | Consumable | 13 | +2.5% Critical chance, Duration 1 minute | |
| Scroll of Scholar Lore | Consumable | 24 | +3.5% Critical chance, Duration 1 minute | |
| Scroll of Elder Scholar Lore | Consumable | 30 | +7.5% Critical chance, Duration 1 minute | |
| Scroll of Ancient Scholar Lore | Consumable | 40 | +10% Critical chance, Duration 1 minute | |
| Scroll of Supreme Scholar Lore | Consumable | 50 | +12.5% Critical chance, Duration 1 minute | |
| Item Type | Craft | Material Components | Base Material Components | Critical Component | Skill gain per make | Total Skill gain per make |
| Bronze Scholar's Glass | Metalsmith | 4 Bronze Ingots, 1 Rough Glass Lens | 4 Chunks of Copper Ore, 4 Chunks of Tin Ore, 1 Rough Glass Lens | Chunk of Crude Brimstone | 8 | 8 |
| Iron Scholar's Glass | Metalsmith | 4 Low-grade Steel Ingots, 1 Fine Glass Lens | 8 Chunks of Barrow-iron Ore, 4 Lumps of Coal, 1 Fine Glass Lens | Chunk of Pale Brimstone | 8 | 8 |
| Steel Scholar's Glass | Metalsmith | 5 High-grade Steel Ingots, 1 Polished Glass Lens | 10 Chunks of Rich Iron Ore, 5 Lumps of Coal, 1 Polished Glass Lens | Chunk of Dark Brimstone | 8 | 8 |
| Dwarf-steel Scholar's Glass | Metalsmith | 5 Dwarf-steel Ingots, 1 Superb Glass Lens | 10 Chunks of Dwarf-iron Ore, 5 Lumps of Coal, 1 Superb Glass Lens | Chunk of Prilled Brimstone | 8 | 8 |
| Ancient Iron Scholar's Glass | Metalsmith | 4 Elven-steel Ingots, 2 Ancient Iron Ingots, 1 Pristine Glass Lens | 12 Chunks of Ancient Iron Ore, 4 Lumps of Coal, 1 Pristine Glass Lens | Chunk of Dusty Brimstone | 8 | 8 |
| Ancient Steel Scholar's Glass (one-use) | Metalsmith | 6 Ancient Steel Ingots, 2 Elven-Steel Ingots, 1 Pristine Glass Lens, 1 Beryl Shard | 10 Chunks of Ancient Iron Ore, 6 Chunks of Dwarf-iron Ore, 8 Lumps of Coal, 1 Pristine Glass Lens, 1 Beryl Shard | Grand Master Metalworker's Journal | 12 | 12 |
| Tools of the Historian (one-use) | Metalsmith | 6 Khazad-iron Ingots, 3 Khazad-Steel Ingots, 1 Short Mallorn Shaft, 1 Long Mallorn Shaft, 1 Exceptional Glass Lens, 2 Mithril Flakes | 18 Chunks of Khazad-iron Ore, 3 Lumps of Coal, 1 Short Mallorn Shaft, 1 Long Mallorn Shaft, 1 Exceptional Glass Lens, 2 Mithril Flakes | Supreme Master Metalworker's Journal | 12 | 12 |
| Scroll of Minor Scholar Lore (Crit Success makes 3) |
Scholar | 2 Aged Scraps of Text, 1 Early Third Age Relic | 2 Aged Scraps of Text, 1 Early Third Age Relic | Dim Candle | 8 | 8 |
| Scroll of Lesser Scholar Lore (Crit Success makes 3) |
Scholar | 2 Cryptic Text, 1 Ruined Second Age Trinket | 2 Cryptic Text, 1 Ruined Second Age Trinket | Rushlight Candle | 8 | 8 |
| Scroll of Scholar Lore (Crit Success makes 3) |
Scholar | 2 Faded Sindarin Passages, 1 Torn Craftsman's Diary | 2 Faded Sindarin Passages, 1 Torn Craftsman's Diary | Beeswax Candle | 8 | 8 |
| Scroll of Elder Scholar Lore (Crit Success makes 3) |
Scholar | 2 Fragments of Dunedain Script, 1 Relic of Lothlorien | 2 Fragments of Dunedain Script, 1 Relic of Lothlorien | Tallow Candle | 8 | 8 |
| Scroll of Ancient Scholar Lore (Crit Success makes 3) |
Scholar | 2 Long-lost Second Age Texts, 1 Undeciphered Moon-letters | 2 Long-lost Second Age Texts, 1 Undeciphered Moon-letters | Ornate Candle | 8 | 8 |
| Scroll of Supreme Scholar Lore (Crit Success makes 3) |
Scholar | 2 Rune-carved Tablets, 1 Etching of Moria | 2 Rune-carved Tablets, 1 Etching of Moria | Bright Lamp | 8 | 8 |